OFFICIAL | Do you have unpopular k-pop opinions? - allkpop forums (2024)

Share all your unpopular opinions related to k-pop here

Mine: I'm not a fan of the 2NE1 discography.

I acknowledge their achievements and their influence, but their songs are not for me.

Quote from NaomiBlue

Kpop needs better produced, more current music overall to move to the next level internationally. (not a reaction, I say this all the time)

Kpop music production is top notch it just lacks originality.

ICY > Dalla Dalla

Not Shy > Wannabe

Quote from QueenMaknae27

IU is the prettiest kpop female soloist

Is it that unpopular? I think you're absolutely right.

Quote from omnimorphism

Is it that unpopular? I think you're absolutely right.

A lot will say taeyeon or hyuna

Quote from jinaland

Kpop music production is top notch it just lacks originality.

Hm valid - although I'm not sure I agree fully (but that's why it's an interesting topic!) because while often the production is smooth and put together well from a pure sound modulation point of view, there's often a lot of disjointed parts? I know the 'it's noise!' thing is used way too often just for fanwarring, but what can bother me is how it's common to just jump into a 'hype' section or change style too suddenly, if that makes sense?

Like I call it Frankenmusic bc at times it just feels slapped together as opposed to carefully planned out or based on music theory. I love loud, banger music, but I want it to make sense to me from a musical narrative point of view and those beat drops to be earned. The best hiphop and pop producers are masters of making their music satisfying that way. The originality is the other side of it, I agree there - often the best songs in kpop that are laid out well seem like they're heavily influenced by other songs as opposed to fully fresh. (and usually songs a couple of years old at least)

Quote from NaomiBlue

Hm valid - although I'm not sure I agree fully (but that's why it's an interesting topic!) because while often the production is smooth and put together well from a pure sound modulation point of view, there's often a lot of disjointed parts? I know the 'it's noise!' thing is used way too often just for fanwarring, but what can bother me is how it's common to just jump into a 'hype' section or change style too suddenly, if that makes sense?

Like I call it Frankenmusic bc at times it just feels slapped together as opposed to carefully planned out or based on music theory. I love loud, banger music, but I want it to make sense to me from a musical narrative point of view and those beat drops to be earned. The best hiphop and pop producers are masters of making their music satisfying that way. The originality is the other side of it, I agree there - often the best songs in kpop that are laid out well seem like they're heavily influenced by other songs as opposed to fully fresh. (and usually songs a couple of years old at least)

The thing that makes kpop music different from western pop music is it's mixture of genres, arrangement and unconventional composition. Maybe more experimental? We can't expect Billie Eillish or Twenty One Pilots from kpop. But we can expect unorthodox structure and composition from kpop. Maybe it feels disjointed at first. It's because people are not adapted to it. But listening to it after several times you will realise how those unexpected turns are so smooth & fun. Also western music critics are interested in kpop because of this uniqueness, those unexpected beat & melody changes. I follow one Canadian kpop music reviewer and reading his reviews make me appreciate production quality of kpop music more. At the same time western pop music is losing it's originality too. So I think it is a good opportunity for groups like NCT, SKZ and Atee*z. They have really great production team. Not to mention NCT has whole western producers. Also their music feels more up to date and original to me.

Quote from jinaland

The thing that makes kpop music different from western pop music is it's mixture of genres, arrangement and unconventional composition. Maybe more experimental? We can't expect Billie Eillish or Twenty One Pilots from kpop. But we can expect unorthodox structure and composition from kpop. Maybe it feels disjointed at first. It's because people are not adapted to it. But listening to it after several times you will realise how those unexpected turns are so smooth & fun. Also western music critics are interested in kpop because of this uniqueness, those unexpected beat & melody changes. I follow one Canadian kpop music reviewer and reading his reviews make me appreciate production quality of kpop music more. At the same time western pop music is losing it's originality too. So I think it is a good opportunity for groups like NCT, SKZ and Atee*z. They have really great production team. Not to mention NCT has whole western producers. Also their music feels more up to date and original to me.

I respect that, even tho' I disagree!

I personally think NCT, SKZ, and Atee*z are mostly using older EDM sounds and production as opposed to the new, hip-hop banger style techniques and layering they would need to sound current? I see the way it's mixed up as very different. I agree on pop being stale, but I think that's why hip-hop dominates in the west and especially America. Much more creativity and interesting sounds coming out of it. Like listening to the top 20 viral songs on AM and Spotify it's mostly HH and it sounds nothing like kpop. Where kpop sounds like old EDM to me.

But I avoid saying 'western producers' because I think great production can come from anywhere in the world, and often I think Kpop, because it pays less, isn't usually using A++ offerings and producers regardless of where they're from? Also, they need more creative rapping and flows to be respected if they're going with the rap-heavy music styles.

So - but I recognize this is just my opinion! - I don't think NCT/SKZ/ATZ will break big until they do have 2021 tiktok sounds if they want to be noisey and they freshen up their rap.

Quote from NaomiBlue

I respect that, even tho' I disagree!

I personally think NCT, SKZ, and Atee*z are mostly using older EDM sounds and production as opposed to the new, hip-hop banger style techniques and layering they would need to sound current? I see the way it's mixed up as very different. I agree on pop being stale, but I think that's why hip-hop dominates in the west and especially America. Much more creativity and interesting sounds coming out of it. Like listening to the top 20 viral songs on AM and Spotify it's mostly HH and it sounds nothing like kpop. Where kpop sounds like old EDM to me.

But I avoid saying 'western producers' because I think great production can come from anywhere in the world, and often I think Kpop, because it pays less, isn't usually using A++ offerings and producers regardless of where they're from? Also, they need more creative rapping and flows to be respected if they're going with the rap-heavy music styles.

So - but I recognize this is just my opinion! - I don't think NCT/SKZ/ATZ will break big until they do have 2021 tiktok sounds if they want to be noisey and they freshen up their rap.

Display More

Quote from omnimorphism

Is it that unpopular? I think you're absolutely right.

her beauty is so ethereal im no my knees

I actually like the auto tune here and there :D

But not when it’s used in attempts to cover up the lack of vocal skills tho...

Its okay to say an idol is unattractive and still stan them

Saying theyre outright ugly is rude obviously but saying you dont find them attractive doesnt make you a "fake fan". Youre not going to find everyone in kpop attractive, Is it rlly that hard to understand? smh

Quote from zanded

K-Pop instrumentals, as well layered and mixed as they can be, are out of touch with international audiences due to their low volume.

I'm not talking about EDM (or as some K-Pop fans like to call it, 'noise') music, but that instrumentals in general need to be louder relative to vocals. It's obvious that companies are trying to appeal to international fans yet the chart-topping songs in most parts of Europe/North America/South America have distinct, loud tracks which overshadow the vocals at times.

This has been the trend for a better part of a decade now. I'm frustrated that K-Pop tracks often hide their amazing productions behind vocals for no good reason. Just a few examples of K-Pop songs which did a better job at this (and were subsequently popular among international fans) are Black Swan, Dynamite, Back Door, Feel Good, BOSS, Bang Bang Bang, HYLT, Kill This Love, 4D, etc...

I suppose it's a trait of pop music to have the melody predominantly narrated by vocals but that's quickly fading from relevance even in Pop music. Although some companies / artists are adapting, it's a rather slow process and I feel that it hampers K-Pop's ability to achieve mainstream relevance internationally.

Display More

What? I always think it's the exact opposite. I always feel like the instrumental overpowers the vocals and I want to hear richer vocals form the idols

Quote from SunriseSeulgi

stayc so bad and weeekly tag me were the best gg debuts in 2020

Stop reading my mind.

Quote from glowello

What? I always think it's the exact opposite. I always feel like the instrumental overpowers the vocals and I want to hear richer vocals form the idols

I also have the feeling that the instrumentals are pretty high volume in K-pop and sometimes it sounds like they are competing with or overpowering the vocals. I also prefer more focus on the vocals.

Quote from omnimorphism

Is it that unpopular? I think you're absolutely right.

I think shes an elite visual if she were a kpop idol

jimin tae jungkook have the best visuals in bts