Last updated Jan 31, 2024
Justin Fischer
Jeep has some of the worst reliability ratings of any automaker today, but some models are considerably better than others. We had originally planned to identify the five most reliable Jeep models, but we ran into a problem. None of the nine Jeep models earns higher than 3 out of 5 stars for reliability. Therefore, we’ve listed the models from most reliable to least reliable, according to Consumer Reports testing and surveys.
Overall, the Jeep brand ranks #24 out of the 25 car brands that CR tests for reliability. Who scored worse? Believe it or not, it was Mercedes-Benz.
We also included current inventory numbers, and there are A LOT of Jeeps sitting on dealer lots today. The deals are out there, if you learn how to negotiate. More on that below.
Contents hide
1 Jeep Cherokee
2 Jeep Wagoneer
3 Jeep Grand Wagoneer
4 Jeep Grand Cherokee
5 Jeep Grand Cherokee L
6 Jeep Wrangler
7 Jeep Gladiator
8 Jeep Compass
9 Jeep Renegade
10 Navigating Reliability Ratings: Final Thoughts
Jeep Cherokee
Base Price: $37,695
Current Nationwide Inventory:198 market days of supply
Reliability Rating: 3/5
Satisfaction Rating: 2/5
Overall Score: 64
About the rating: Despite receiving a face-lift, new minor features, and a turbocharged engine option, the refreshed Jeep Cherokee remains a lackluster model in a competitive segment. It continues to suffer from transmission issues, a stiff ride, and uninspiring handling. The optional turbo engine fails to provide a noticeable improvement in performance. While Jeep addressed some design concerns, this updated version falls short of expectations, highlighting the gap between its promising specs and on-road performance.
See Jeep Cherokee listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Wagoneer
Base Price: $61,595
Current Nationwide Inventory: 260 market days of supply
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 3/5
Overall Score: 51
About the rating: The all-new Wagoneer, built on the Ram 1500 pickup’s body-on-frame construction, offers a comfortable three-row experience with seating for up to 8. However, its pricing, starting at about $10,000 more than competitors before factoring in a high $2,000 destination charge, raises eyebrows. The 5.7-liter V8 engine delivers a robust 392 horsepower, but it’s accompanied by very poor fuel economy, achieving just 15 mpg overall. The independent rear suspension contributes to a smooth ride, but the SUV’s bulk becomes apparent in corners and turns. Inside, the cabin boasts space, leather, and upscale materials, although some controls and displays are less user-friendly. Safety features like forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking come standard, with optional advanced driver assistance features available.
See Jeep Wagoneer listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Grand Wagoneer
Base Price: $91,140
Current Nationwide Inventory:264 market days of supply
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 3/5
Overall Score: Not Tested
About the rating: Consumer Reports says that the Grand Wagoneer’s expected reliability and satisfaction ratings are based on similar models, which in this case, is surely the 2023 Wagoneer that was tested.
See Jeep Grand Wagoneer listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Base Price: $36,495
Current Nationwide Inventory:200 market days of supply
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 3/5
Overall Score: 55
About the rating: The redesigned Grand Cherokee offers a more premium cabin, improved fuel economy, and added refinement compared to its predecessor. It retains the same core powertrain, a 293-horsepower 3.6-liter V6, delivering smooth acceleration and linear power delivery. While it handles relatively well for its size, it falls short of the agility of competitors like the Ford Explorer. The cabin is quiet and well-finished with ample space and comfortable front seats. However, some controls are cluttered and confusing, and the instrument cluster changes can be distracting. The Grand Cherokee comes with a standard suite of safety features, but its historically below-average reliability may deter some buyers.
See Jeep Grand Cherokee listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Grand Cherokee L
Base Price: $42,130
Current Nationwide Inventory: 175 market days of supply
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 3/5
Overall Score: 53
About the rating: The Grand Cherokee’s long-awaited three-row “L” version bridges the gap between mainstream and luxury SUVs but has performance limitations. The base 290-horsepower V6 struggles with acceleration and gets 19 mpg overall. It handles reasonably well, but the steering lacks feedback, and tire grip is mediocre. The cabin is spacious but may not comfortably accommodate adults in the third row. The interior has glossy-black trim, wood, and some misaligned panels, and the controls are cluttered. Connectivity is good, and safety features are standard, but it’s not ideal for serious off-roading.
See Jeep Grand Cherokee L listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Wrangler
Base Price: $32,095
Current Nationwide Inventory: 224 market days of supply
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 3/5
Overall Score: 25
About the rating: The current Jeep Wrangler maintains its rustic charm, iconic design, and off-road capabilities while enhancing its powertrain, amenities, and connectivity features. However, it comes with drawbacks such as awkward access, excessive wind noise, and a rough ride. The Wrangler’s body-on-frame construction, solid axles, and removable features cater to off-road enthusiasts, especially the Rubicon version. Nevertheless, its on-road performance falls short of modern SUV standards, with stiff handling, pronounced body roll, and a jittery ride, making it less suitable for daily commuting or highway driving. In conclusion, the Wrangler excels in off-road adventures but is not a good choice for any other driving scenarios.
See Jeep Wrangler listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Gladiator
Base Price: $38,775
Current Nationwide Inventory: 190 market days of inventory
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 3/5
Overall Score: 36
About the rating: The Jeep Gladiator, essentially a Wrangler-based pickup truck with a 5-foot bed, inherits many of the Wrangler’s pros and cons. It stands out in the small truck class due to its unique character and better ride quality, thanks to a rear suspension borrowed from the Ram 1500. Off-road capabilities are impressive, and it offers a robust 3.6-liter V6 engine with good towing capacity, though fuel economy is average. On the downside, handling is clumsy, and the cabin lacks some comfort features, including power seat adjustments. Wind noise can be bothersome at highway speeds, and while it’s appealing for off-road enthusiasts, its higher price and optional safety features may give potential buyers pause.
See Jeep Gladiator listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Compass
Base Price: $28,400
Current Nationwide Inventory:210 market days of inventory
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 1/5
Overall Score: Not Tested
About the rating: Consumer Reports says that the Jeep Compass’ expected reliability and satisfaction ratings are based on similar models, which in this case, is likely the Cherokee and Renegade, which were tested. Consumer Reports did drive the Compass, however, and didn’t find much to like about it. CR says that when compared to its competitors, the Compass falls short in various aspects. It offers a stiff and jittery ride, and the rear seat is both low and flat, detracting from its overall appeal.
See Jeep Compass listings with the power of local market data.
Jeep Renegade
Base Price: $28,343
Current Nationwide Inventory:194 market days of inventory
Reliability Rating: 2/5
Satisfaction Rating: 1/5
Overall Score: 40
About the rating: Don’t buy a Jeep just for the brand name. The Jeep Renegade boasts a modern design and a solid build, offering decent rear cargo space. However, its charm wanes quickly due to cumbersome handling, a choppy ride, uncomfortable front seats, and limited visibility. The nine-speed automatic transmission can be hesitant, paired with the 2.4-liter engine, affecting power and performance. While its Trailhawk version shines off-road, the Renegade faces tough competition from more refined and economical compact SUVs like the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4. With a score
See Jeep Renegade listings with the power of local market data.
Navigating Reliability Ratings: Final Thoughts
While reliability is a crucial factor in choosing your next vehicle, it’s essential to consider other elements. Factors like fuel efficiency, comfort, safety features, and the car’s total cost of ownership play significant roles in your decision-making process. While we understand that every driver has their own preferences, there’s an undeniable truth car buyers must confront: Jeep does not score well in any of these categories.
From ride comfort to fuel economy, maintenance costs to recalls, Jeep is not a top performer. But we get it: Jeep makes offroad adventures possible at an affordable price point. That’s something special, so we’re sure Jeep will continue to do well in the future. However, we hope that Jeep does improve the common complaints and faults, with the simple goal of having a better product in the future.
You’re not alone in this journey! Our dedicated team of CarEdge Coaches is here to assist you every step of the way. With expert advice and personalized guidance, we ensure you not only choose a reliable vehicle but one that truly fits your lifestyle and brings joy to every drive. Ready to embark on a stress-free and informed car-buying adventure? Contact a CarEdge Coach today, and let’s find your next car at a price you can afford!!
Love the daily Ray and Zach show? Check out our new podcast, AutoInsiders with Ray Shefska!
